You are the arbitrator tasked with deciding this case. The question you must answer is: Did the employer violate the provisions of the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) when it deni
Instructions
After reviewing the description (attached) Read the scenario detailing the labor relations grievance you'll be discussing (Attached). Then, answer the three questions below.
The answer to each question should have its own dedicated paragraph, consisting of approximately 4-6 sentences each. This assignment is a writing/research exercise, so please verbalize self-created full sentences in paragraph form, and refrain from using bullet-style lists.
Discussion Questions
- You are the arbitrator tasked with deciding this case. The question you must answer is: Did the employer violate the provisions of the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) when it denied bereavement leave to the grievant? Explain your reasoning. As part of your response, identify the relevant language from Article 23 of the CBA that led to your decision. (Hint: remember you are a neutral third-party and your primary responsibility is to interpret the language of the CBA)
- Describe some actions that both the employer and the union could have taken to avoid this conflict. Be specific.
The “You Be the Arbitrator” discussions will present you with a scenario including (a) the facts of an actual labor relations grievance, and (b) the positions of both the management and the union. Students will play the role of arbitrator (similar to a judge) and decide the outcome of the case.
Description
Students will be provided with the details of an actual grievance case that could not be decided by management and union representatives. Therefore, the case has been referred to an arbitrator to make a “final and binding” decision both parties have agreed to accept. Students will play the role of an arbitrator (judge) and carefully read the facts, relevant section(s) of the collective bargaining agreement (CBA), and the positions of the parties. Then, you will answer some discussion questions.
Part of the discussion asks you to render a decision as a neutral, third-party arbitrator. This is often referred to as an "award and opinion."
Arbitrator decisions contain two parts. The first part involves an “award” that one side has asked for, but the other side hasn’t agreed to. For example, in cases involving a terminated employee, the union may ask that the employee be reinstated and given back pay equal to the pay they missed. The award might or might not grant one or both requests. The second part is an “opinion.” This is a statement explaining the rationale behind the award, often citing critical facts of the case, a position of one of the parties, or even common sense. However, it should not simply be a personal opinion.
To determine the award and opinion, you should look first to the relevant section(s) of the collective bargaining agreement (CBA), which will be provided in the discussion prompt. The language of the CBA is the most important factor to be considered by an arbitrator. If the CBA language does not enable the arbitrator to make a decision, then they should examine the facts and other evidence from the case, past practices (what actions were taken in similar cases), relevant facts from past negotiations, and common industry practice to reach a decision.
Other aspects of the discussion will ask you to (a) identify the key sections, phrases, or words from the CBA that were critical in making your decision, and (b) explain what actions the employer and/or the union might have taken to avoid this conflict.
The keys to making good arbitration decisions include: (1) remain objective – set aside any feelings about unions and management, (2) use the language of the CBA for direction – if it’s vague or if two sections conflict, consider what was the likely intention of the negotiators, (3) consider past practice – the lack of consistency compared to similar cases may be significant, and (4) does the penalty equal the offense? In some cases, guilt is not the issue, but rather, was the penalty equal to the level of the offense?
,
YOU BE THE ARBITRATOR Bereavement Leave
ARTICLE 23 BEREAVEMENT LEAVE
Section 23.1. If a death occurs in the employee’s immediate family (spouse, children), employee’s family (mother, father, stepparents), a grandfather, grandmother, father-in-law, mother- in-law, person in loco parentis, and any member of the employee’s family residing in the employee’s residence, such employee shall be granted three (3) days’ funeral leave, consecutive and contigu- ous to the death without loss of pay, benefits, days off, holidays, or vacation time, provided that such leave may be extended, within discretion of the Sheriff, based on individual circumstances. If the death requires that the employee travel more than 200 miles, the Sheriff may, at the request of the employee, allow up to two (2) additional workdays as a bereavement leave.
Facts
The employer provides the statutory law enforcement services to the citizens of Fulton County, Ohio. The grievant is a deputy. The grievant worked on the night shift, and his days off were Wednesday and Thursday. On the evening of Thursday, June 21, the grievant’s paternal grandmother died. The grievant was not informed of her death until after he had finished his shift on Friday, June 22. He was also informed that the funeral was going to be Sunday, June 24. The grievant reported for work for his regular shift on Saturday, June 23. The grievant then informed his supervisor of the death and indicated that he would be taking Sunday, June 24, off to attend the funeral. The grievant’s request was approved, and the grievant then requested two additional days of bereavement leave, that is, Monday, June 25, and Tuesday, June 26, which was made known to the grievant’s supervisors. The grievant filled out a “Request for Leave” form as required. However, after the fact, the employer reviewed his request in light of the collective bargaining agreement (CBA)
and decided the grievant was not entitled to bereavement pay for Tuesday on the ground that the three days of bereavement leave here should have been Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. Nevertheless, the employer chose only to disallow the Tuesday bereavement pay. The grievant appealed.
Issue
Did the employer violate the provisions of the CBA when it denied bereavement leave to the grievant?
Position of the Parties
The employer argues that under the CBA, the grant of three days’ funeral leave must be consecutive and contiguous to the death (see Article 23, Bereavement Leave). So grievant was entitled to bereavement pay only for Sunday, as the death occurred on Thursday. The approval of any extension of that leave is within the discre- tion of the sheriff, who in this instance approved one day of the extension, Monday. Therefore, the grievant is not en- titled to bereavement pay for Tuesday.
The union argues that the CBA does not require that the three bereavement days begin on the “first day” after the death, just that the days be near the death and be consecutive and contiguous to each other. When the employer approved the grievant’s request for Sunday off, the three days of bereavement began, which means Monday and Tuesday should also count as bereavement days.
Source: Adapted from Fulton County Sheriff, 116 LA 1773 (Arb. 2002).
Who We Are
We are a professional custom writing website. If you have searched a question and bumped into our website just know you are in the right place to get help in your coursework.
Do you handle any type of coursework?
Yes. We have posted over our previous orders to display our experience. Since we have done this question before, we can also do it for you. To make sure we do it perfectly, please fill our Order Form. Filling the order form correctly will assist our team in referencing, specifications and future communication.
Is it hard to Place an Order?
1. Click on the “Place order tab at the top menu or “Order Now” icon at the bottom and a new page will appear with an order form to be filled.
2. Fill in your paper’s requirements in the "PAPER INFORMATION" section and click “PRICE CALCULATION” at the bottom to calculate your order price.
3. Fill in your paper’s academic level, deadline and the required number of pages from the drop-down menus.
4. Click “FINAL STEP” to enter your registration details and get an account with us for record keeping and then, click on “PROCEED TO CHECKOUT” at the bottom of the page.
5. From there, the payment sections will show, follow the guided payment process and your order will be available for our writing team to work on it.